Windowless Comfort

August 28, 2009

Wall Paper Windows at Q Club in Isla Verde- one of the few typologies expected to have windowless comfort.

Why have operable windows if you could have floor to ceiling glass panels that protect you from the heat, smell, and noise of the city? A new concerning trend – windowless comfort – is becoming popular in many tropical countries. People are not only now willing to live windowless, but this typology of city living is being seen as one of the most exclusive ways to dwell in the urban (and not so urban) parts of San Juan.

Why should this raise concern? In cities such as Toronto for example, this trend is somewhat adequate since the operable windows are closed most of the year due to the cold climate or half open during warmer months.


My room in Toronto. Average Outside Temperature in the Winter: 30 F

In Puerto Rico on the other hand, this imported trend is concerning since these glass panels usually have minimal or no existing shading systems and it converts interior spaces into what is commonly called “heated fishbowls”. In tropical climates, this type of buildings is not only eco-scary, but also uncomfortable if you choose not to turn on the air conditioner for as little as 30 minutes.

Apartment for Sale in Miramar with no operable windows in the living room, except for a sliding door to access the balcony.
When I visited this project featured above – the sales manager told me they chose to have minimal amount of windows since the space was built for air conditioning. She said the main reason for this was the heat (of course!), and the noise of the avenues surrounding the building. Then, when I asked for the average maintenance costs of these units, including the keeping of air conditioned common spaces 24/7, she said…well, the estimate is about $2,000 a month per apartment.
Now, that made me sweat, even when it was a comfortable 70 degrees inside that sunny apartment.

A Breezy Train Ride in San Juan

August 22, 2009




A permeable wall system allows cross ventilation while providing security in the San Francisco Station

It could be one of the hottest days of the summer and you will feel fresh taking the train in San Juan. Built in 2005, all stations of El Tren Urbano (The Urban Train of San Juan) were commissioned to local architects and artists of Puerto Rico. This gave them the opportunity to be a vital part of this transportation tool, seen by many as a key to the modernization of this Caribbean city.
Most stations of the train were planned to be elevated instead of being underground. This condition allowed having cross ventilation and natural sunlight throughout every station. The firm Sierra, Cardona y Ferrer was responsible for the design of stations such as Hato Rey, San Francisco, Jardines, Martinez Nadal, among others.

Some of these stations are featured below, each having simple strategies for thermal comfort that make them sustainable and fresh, even during hot days.


Outdoor Platform andc Prefabricated Brise Soleil in Hato Rey Station


Outdoor Art Mural in Jardines Station


Green Wall cooling platform in Martinez Nadal Station


Metal Perforated Panels in Roosevelt Station allow air to come through the waiting platform.

Air Conditioned Facades

August 14, 2009



The air conditioner is a vital technology to achieve thermal comfort in hot climates, especially when buildings are designed with poor cross ventilation, low ceilings and few or no operable windows. For many, the air conditioner is a symbol of comfort, modernity, and social status. As soon as people can pay for one and the monthly electricity bill that comes with it, its box is placed indiscriminately in the opening of a window, a balcony, a roof, or anywhere else that fits. But it is difficult to ignore the visual effect that air conditioners’ boxes have in the façades of buildings and the general aesthetic effect that these have in our city. While new projects have central air conditioning systems with hidden exhaust structures located on the roof, older or refurbished buildings expose these boxes in a variety of ways – in sometimes interesting and sometimes not so interesting ways.



Buildings in Ashford Ave. in Condado





I wanted to show the many ways in which these boxes are incorporated in the façade design of the buildings – especially the ones built in the 80’s and early 90s around the areas of El Condado, Miramar, Santurce, and Rio Piedras. Unlike contemporary projects, these structures that hide or incorporate the outside boxes of air conditioners were smart because they allowed inhabitants to choose whether to have an air conditioner – without affecting the look of the building on the outside. It is interesting to review this particular strategy, especially at a time when electricity costs are rampant and the impact on the environment is even more alarming.



Buildings in Miramar



Building around Rio Piedras area.






Building in Wilson St, Condado




Building in Ave. Fernandez Juncos, Miramar and Building in Calle Loiza, Condado


Walk up Fever - A Fresh Option in Ponce

July 31, 2009


Walk up complexes had taken the island by storm since the 1980's and are still seen today as an excellent opportunity to own an affordable place in the suburbs. It could be said that the suburban area of Guaynabo is what it is today (seen by many as an "expensive and prestigious" suburban community), thanks to this typology of living. In a matter of a decade, Guaynabo has turned from being a lush countryside town to an overpopulated area full of walk ups and expensive neighborhoods. Now developers have less cheap land in Guaynabo to get and are selling walk ups with a price tag of normal size houses. For many this type of housing is preferred since it is seen as a more secure, affordable and low maintenance option compared to a regular house.

Site plan and Perspective of Alborada showing all parking located underground and periferal balconies/circulation routes.



Currently under construction, Alborada is a new Walk up complex located in Ponce, Puerto Rico designed by Pina and Associates. This Walk up features simple strategies for thermal comfort that can be viewed as a unique example to follow for other projects of this type. Among these strategies are: underground parking lots, central courtyards, outdoor spaces though most of its periphery, high ceilings, upper section windows and cross ventilation in all circulation routes.





What makes this project unique as a walk up complex is the fact that every building is organized around a central courtyard, giving each apartment an opportunity for cross ventilation and maximum sunlight.








High ceilings located in common recreational areas are great for warm weather since the hot air rises and the spaces below stay cooler naturally. It is ideal to have openings in the upper section of the wall structure to allow this hot air to escape and circulate.




Open circulation routes in stairs and hallways allow air to move freely across these areas.




The placement of all parking spaces under each of the buildings replaces the common practice of surrounding the walk ups with black tar and spaces for cars, leaving it instead for a natural landscape and common areas.



For this blog post, all drawings and photos have been provided by Evelio Pina.

Caguas Police Headquarters

July 23, 2009


view of perforated interior courtyard - secondary entrance



Commissioned to Coleman-Davis Pagan architects, this building for the police department in Caguas has an elegant façade that intimidates when you drive by it. This was precisely the vision when it was conceived right after 9/11 and the firm was asked to create a structure that would communicate protection, invulnerability, and power. Its exposed concrete and massive front façade reminds us of a Brutalist building from the 1970’s. Unlike other brutalism examples, its interior and function is a mystery at a first glance. The windows are placed mysteriously in perpendicular planes throughout the periphery of the building and all interior courtyard spaces are hidden behind a massive wall facing the main avenue in the front.



wind/light tunnels - Front Facade view


Being already familiarized with this firm’s work, I was curious to see what kind of thermal comfort strategies were behind this building, since most of their work is pretty fresh and unique. After a short interview with firm's Principal, Jose Coleman and architect, Victor Nieto at their office in Ocean Park, I was pleased to discover that the building had several elements that made it interesting and sensible to its tropical context.


wind/light tunnels on roof


posterior view

The main entrance consists of an interior yard with small trees that welcomes the visitors into the building. This patio is enclosed by a tall wall that protects the space and channels the air across the front of the building, creating a great opportunity for natural ventilation.The roof structures featured in these photos act as wind and light tunnels connected to the office corridors and mechanical garages, making them bright and naturally ventilated. Also, the strategic placement of two interior courtyards at each side of the main office building that protect against direct sun exposure. The walls surrounding each courtyard are perforated with horizontal slats in the concrete providing ventilation, while at the same acting as protective barriers to the offices inside.

This building is not open to the public yet, but next time you drive by Caguas, don't forget to try to take a peak through its slats. Even if you can not look inside, there is still a lot to see on the outside of this unique structure.


view of interior gardens behind the front facade

Converted Balconies - Condado

July 16, 2009



Conceived at first as a suburb of the main city of Old San Juan, El Condado was built around 1908 by the Behn Brothers, two American industrialists who had a greater passion for real estate than for urban planning. By the middle decades of the 20th century, El Condado had transformed from being just a wealthy suburb to an important pedestrian-oriented residential and tourist center in San Juan. To this day, El Condado is seen as a much desired area to own an apartment, since it offers all the benefits from living in an ocean side community that is well connected to many other important areas of the city such as Santurce and Hato Rey.



apartment for rent - online posting found for Condado del Mar

But after living a few weeks in my rented apartment in the area, I had noticed that all that surrounded me it is highly neglected zone, which after 100 years of its conception, was showing major signs of lack of urban planning. While newly constructed high-rise buildings try to compete for an ocean view, residents of the older buildings get fewer breeze, lots of traffic and minimal water pressure. While the older buildings get warmer with the rampant urban density that surrounds them, their residents try to look for strategies for thermal comfort in order to deal with the heat and the stagnant air. One of the most common approaches to confront the problem is to convert the balconies into air conditioned sun rooms or simply extending the living room to the space that once had this elevated outdoor room.





But I wondered - why do they convert into more and get less? For Malaysian architect, Ken Yeang, balconies are the connection to the outdoors, to the city, to nature. For him, the balcony or any elevated outdoor common space is where the architect has the opportunity to make a high rise building adaptable and relevant to the tropical climate. The balcony then becomes a “buffer” zone to condition and connect the apartment to its surroundings. In my opinion, if this space is eliminated, the apartment immediately feels as an impersonal floating box waiting to be cooled by artificial air conditioning.

Having this in my mind, I asked people who lived in the area about their reasons for converting their balconies or for keeping them. This is what I found: (listed in order of popularity)

Reason 1: The apartment rises in value when the balcony is converted into a closed space since the square footage that counts for the appraisal is the one that is “enclosed”.

Reason 2: The balcony was too hot or sunny and they preferred to have an extended living room with shade and air conditioning.

Reason 3: Their street was too noisy and they could not even talk in the living room before converting the balcony.

Reason 4: Could not convert the balcony (even if he wanted to) since the agreement in his building prohibited any changes to the façade.

Reason 5: Never used the balcony because it had the air conditioning box that occupies more than half of the space available.

Reason 6: Preferred to close the apartment completely since the salt from the sea was damaging all his furniture and electronics.

So after investigating a little further it turns out that there are many reasons for converting the balconies and that all these factors should be taken in considerations by designers when designing new buildings or retrofitting the old. Balconies should exist, especially during times when energy savings are essential for our planet and our pocketbooks. They should be even bigger, well ventilated and considered an asset to any apartment at the time of evaluating its market value.






Yunque Exhibition Center

July 02, 2009

Since its construction in 1996, The Information Center of El Yunque Tropical Forest has been known as an excellent example of a Puerto Rican design that showcases a fresh space that embraces its natural surroundings. Designed by local architecture firm, Sierra, Cardona & Ferrer, this building features elements that resemble its location in the only Tropical Rainforest in the US National Parks. According to the architects, the structure’s ceiling resembles the forest canopy, and the incorporation of running water in the perimeter of the main exhibit building reminds the visitors of the constant rainfall in the forest. The exhibit section and cafeteria can close or open depending on the function and their pivoting doors make this flexible space easy to integrate to its lush surroundings. Although made mostly of metal (not a very fresh material), the high ceiling structure of the main pavilion that encases a semi-open space makes this rather tectonic building feel very fresh and sensible to its tropical surroundings.




views of roof structure



view of water corridor



shading systems

Plantation Style in Bahia Beach

June 25, 2009

view of golf club house
A few days following my arrival in the island, I was talking to my brother about the creation of this blog and he referred me to Bahía, a new project being developed in the northeastern coast of the island in Rio Grande. He mentioned that there was nothing else more tropical than Bahía Beach and that I had to include it in my blog right away. I was skeptical about the whole fuss regarding the “tropicalness” of the project, especially after looking at projects previously done by the development and design team.


view of pool area

To my surprise - the photos looked pretty good on the web – an incredible coastal setting with low rise “eco-friendly” architecture inspired in the plantation village style. After two failed attempts to see the mysterious and exclusive complex (only residents and visitors could enter, even to take a look), I finally went in - thanks to a relative who had purchased an apartment in one of the finished complexes.
The resort community is settled on 483 acres – a former sugar cane plantation. One of the developers’ strategies to make this project unique was to make it an “eco-resort” by building minimally and working with the existing landscape to accommodate only buildings that would be no taller than the existing plants in the area. Also, in an effort to bring back the original state of the land previous to the sugar cane plantation, the group is now incorporating local flora that is indigenous to the area of Rio Grande. This is making local fauna to return to the area.


Elevator core of apartment complex (left) and view of one of the villas' private terrace (right)

Their plantation style buildings are simple and done in style and with good finishings, but it lacks that tropical authenticity that I was expecting. But I am not sure if it is fair to ask more from a project done by mostly foreign commercial developers. Nonetheless, I found lots of outdoor spaces in common areas such as the Golf Club House, which has an indoor/outdoor restaurant and several seating spaces facing the palm tree-lined shoreline. This makes the project pleasant and takes advantage of the gorgeous tropical surrounding. Also, the pool area is filled with low palm trees and sunshade structures, making it fresh even during the hottest days of the summer.


shading structures at the beach (left) and plexiglass and wood roof at club house (right)

Miami Windows

June 18th, 2009


Miami window in vernacular house in Vieques, PR

Miami windows - they are everywhere, they are ugly and they make us sweat. Everywhere you go, you see them warming the buildings like aluminum heaters in permanent action. They became popular in Puerto Rico around the early 70’s and they are still seen and implemented today from vernacular structures to government buildings. Introduced in the Puerto Rican market by -Miami –Somer company from New Jersey, these white windows, also known as the “jalousie” type quickly became popular in many projects because of their price, versatile installation and security against hurricanes. They were marketed as THE window for the tropics since it was affordable, long lasting and with little or noinsulating capabilities (crucial for cold climates and unfortunately ignored for warm ones). The “Miami” type window, as it is commonly known by Puerto Ricans, is made of an aluminum alloy, which is a much better option than wood since it is not damaged by termites or humidity. But it turns out that aluminum is one of the common metals with the highest thermal conductivity (second after gold, which has the highest). When exposed to the sun, the Miami window heats up immediately and heats all the air that goes through it. As a matter of fact, it acts exactly as an electric heater that you put in your bedroom when it is -30 degrees outside in Toronto!



Original advertising, 1970's
But on a positive note, for this blog I wanted to feature an example of a relatively successful implementation of these windows in a building that is rarely noticed in the area of the University of Puerto Rico. This is “La Torre del Norte” designed by Jose Firpi in 1971. The “North Tower” is one of the main student housing buildings in the UPR and it is not precisely the most beautiful and updated one. Nonetheless, thanks to the successful implementation of the Miami windows, it is a building that needs minimal air conditioning and has excellent cross ventilation in common and private areas. This time Firpi took advantage of this inexpensive type of window by using it continuously from floor to ceiling in every floor. This condition created excellent ventilation of the interior by taking cooler air from the lower part of the window and releasing it in the upper section of the window frame on each level. Also, Firpi oriented the building so that the windows faced north and south and the sun didn’t hit the aluminum windows directly over the course of the day.



Torre del Norte today, view from the street

So next time you pass by Ave. Universidad (University Avenue), take a look at your right when you are in the traffic light. Don’t miss it! For many, this building might look plain or just ugly, but for me it looks fresh and a great and creative use of the Miami windows.


advertisement, july 09